Connect with us

Boxing

Haney claims Norman Win makes him P4P, but critics disagree

Published

on

Image: Devin Haney Says Beating Norman Jr. Makes Him P4P-Worthy

Devin Haney says if he is victorious in his fight against undefeated WBO welterweight champion Brian Norman Jr. on Saturday night, he will deserve to be high on the pound-for-pound list.

Haney (32-0, 16 KO) claims he was on the P4P list for the Ryan Garcia fight but was removed after the defeat. For the record, he finished 6th after defeating Vasily Lomachenko and Regis Prograis in back-to-back fights.

Norman’s Slender Plate

The problem with Haney’s belief that the victory over Norman Jr. (28-0, 22 KO) would put him on a top 10 P4P list is that he’s not on it. Moreover, Norman Jr. he had not defeated any significant opponent in his career, and yet he was elevated to the WBO welterweight title.

Haney doesn’t say who he should replace on the list to make the top 10. What did he look like in fights with Jose Ramirez, Ryan Garcia and Vasily Lomachenko It’s not worth the price, is it?

Ring magazine’s top 10 pound-for-pound (P4P) results.

  1. Terence Crawford
  2. Aleksander Usyk
  3. Naoya Inoue
  4. Dmitry Bivol
  5. Artur Beterbiew
  6. Jesse Rodriguez
  7. Junto Nakatani
  8. Shakur Stevenson
  9. David Benavidez
  10. Canelo Alvarez

Fans would ridicule Devin if he argued that he deserved to be rated higher by fans than Canelo, Benavidez, Shakur, Nakatani, “Bam” Rodriguez, Beterbiev, Bivol, Inoue or Usyk. If Ring Magazine gave him a high ranking, it would look bad.

P4P policy in the game

Fans are already criticizing their rankings as political for placing Crawford above Usyk at the top of the P4P list. However, removing one of the top 10 players from the list to include Haney would be just as bad.

“With Ryan [Garcia] fighting, I was taken off the pound-for-pound list, or at least some people’s list. But I think this is a fight that will put me back on that list, high on that list,” said Devin Haney Ring Magazine on his belief that defeating WBO welterweight champion Brian Norman Jr. on Saturday would be worth adding to the pound-for-pound list.

What exactly does Haney have to do

For Haney to be on the P4P list, he would have to do more than just beat Norman Jr. This would be a good start for him, but he would need to put together several solid performances in a row. He didn’t do it.

Required wins required by Haney for P4P consideration

  1. Brian Norman Jr.
  2. Jaron Ennis
  3. Gary Antuanne Russell
  4. Teofimo Lopez

In his last four fights, Haney has had three penniless performances he should have two defeats. A 2-2 record in his last four fights is not P4P worthy.

  • Jose Ramirez: Win – unanimous decision in 12 rounds
  • Ryan Garcia: Lost – 12-round majority decision
  • Regis Prograis: Win – unanimous decision in 12 rounds
  • Vasily Lomachenko: Win – (controversial) unanimous decision in 12 rounds

“It would show what type of fighter I am. In my first fight, I’m fighting the best guy at 147 pounds. I didn’t make any adjustments or look for the guy who would be the easiest to win the world title,” Haney said. “I went and faced the best guy. He’s just a pound-for-pound fighter. He’s a pound-for-pound champion.”

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Boxing

Davies vs Collins & Heaney vs Warburton II Results: Full Fight Recap

Published

on

"Davies vs Collins & Heaney vs Warburton II Results: Full Fight Recap"

World Boxing News provides results and updates as Liam Davies faces Nathaniel Collins in the main event at bp pulse LIVE in Birmingham.

Davies and Collins collide over 12 rounds for the EBU European featherweight title at the top of the Queensberry Promotions card.

Luke McCormack faces Kay Prospere for the vacant British super lightweight title, while Bradley Goldsmith takes on Amir Abubaker for the IBF International middleweight title.

WBN provides results and updates from every bout as they happen.


Results

All times are local BST.

23:11

Gerome Warburton defeated Nathan Heaney for the second time running as the middleweight put an exclamation mark on his first victory.

Heaney walks away from the sport having been an entertainer through a long carer, without reaching the heights of a world title.

22:04

Liam Davies improved to 19-1 after Nathaniel Collins retired at the end of the seventh round due to a cut over his right eye. Collins had also been dropped in the opening round as Davies successfully defended the European featherweight title.

21:22

Bradley Goldsmith improved to 17-1 with a seventh-round stoppage of Amir Abubaker to retain his IBF International middleweight title. Abubaker went down in the fourth and three times in the seventh before the finish at 2:42.

20:10

Lewis Richardson improved to 3-0 with a shutout six-round points victory over Ivan Trofimovich, earning a 60-54 decision.

19:56

Luke McCormack moved to 6-0 and claimed the vacant British super lightweight title with a tenth-round knockout of Kay Prospere, who was counted out after a right uppercut at 1:28.

18:55

Michael Hussain moved to 5-0 with a four-round points victory over Nabil Ahmed, earning a 39-38 decision.

18:11

Nelson Birchall moved to 12-0 with a third-round stoppage of Lewis Morris, who went down before the finish came at 1:12. Lasha Guruli also remained unbeaten at 5-0 after edging Hughie Wilson 77-75 over eight rounds.

17:22

Early action saw John Tom Varey and Reese Lynch claim four-round victories to move to 3-0 and 5-0 respectively.


TV Coverage

DAZN provides full worldwide coverage.

Follow WBN’s live boxing coverage throughout the event.


About the Author

Phil Jay is the Editor-in-Chief of World Boxing News (WBN), a BWAA-acknowledged boxing news website founded in 2010. A veteran boxing reporter with 16 years of experience, he has interviewed world champions, broken international exclusives, and reported ringside from major events. His work is published worldwide through WBN and distributed on platforms including Apple News.

Read Phil Jay’s full bio and latest stories.

Continue Reading

Boxing

Janibek Alimkhanuly Shifts Perspective on Hamzah Sheeraz: A New Dynamic in Boxing

Published

on

"Janibek Alimkhanuly Shifts Perspective on Hamzah Sheeraz: A New Dynamic in Boxing"

Janibek Alimkhanuly spent months trying to get Hamzah Sheeraz into the ring. Now that Sheeraz has vacated his WBO super middleweight title, Janibek is asking fans to stop saying the former champion ran from him. That is generous. It also leaves Janibek with less to say about a fight he wanted badly.

Janibek’s tone has changed since the purse bid. He was eager to fight, said money was not his priority, and publicly pushed Sheeraz to accept. Queensberry then bid $1,001,809 to stage the ordered defense, beating Top Rank’s $820,000 offer. Sheeraz’s 75 percent share would have been roughly $751,000. Days later, he gave up the belt.

That sequence deserves a closer look. Queensberry put a serious number on the fight, so the bid itself cannot be dismissed as proof that nobody valued it. But winning the right to promote a title defense means little to fans when the champion vacates before it happens.

Sheeraz has objected to Janibek receiving a mandatory shot after his failed drug test. He is entitled to explain that position. Fans are equally entitled to ask why the issue reached a purse bid before he surrendered the title. Janibek’s post supplies no answer.

Perhaps Janibek sees no benefit in branding Sheeraz a coward. Doing so would also make the opponent he chased sound less valuable. Calling Sheeraz a great fighter preserves the idea that this was an important contest, even after the belt and the fight slipped away.

The respect between them may be sincere. Janibek still gets no Sheeraz fight, and Sheeraz no longer has to defend his title against Janibek. A friendly photo does not change either result.

Share this article

About the author

Boxing 24/7 Wire

Boxing247.com is an independent boxing news publication covering the sport since 2001. It provides original reporting, fight analysis, schedules, results, and informed coverage of major fighters and events worldwide, backed by more than 25 years of professional boxing journalism.

Continue Reading

Boxing

Virginia Confirms Decision to Erase Prichard Colón Loss from Records

Published

on

Virginia Confirms Decision to Erase Prichard Colón Loss from Records

Virginia has given World Boxing News its final answer on whether Prichard Colón’s last professional defeat can still be challenged, bringing an end to WBN’s long fight to have the result annulled and removed from his record.

WBN has pursued the possibility of changing the controversial disqualification defeat to Terrel Williams, with those efforts continuing following Colón’s death at age 33.

Virginia’s Department of Professional and Occupational Regulation previously explained that a decision can only be overturned if there is proven collusion, a scorecard error, or a regulatory violation that affected the result.

WBN pressed Eric Beidel, Communications & Digital Media Manager for the Department of Professional & Occupational Regulation, on whether any avenue remained to challenge the decision.

“And on that final question … as mentioned before, a decision can only be overturned if there is proven collusion, a scorecard error, or a regulatory violation that affected the results,” Beidel graciously responded after providing WBN with transparent answers throughout the investigation.

“In addition, a complaint about a regulatory violation must be filed within three years of the alleged violation.”

The Colón-Williams fight took place on October 17, 2015, meaning that deadline expired years ago.

Virginia Closes Appeal Route

Virginia’s response also addressed whether the result could instead be challenged through an appeal.

“The Administrative Process Act (APA) does create appeal rights to case decisions, but because DPOR never received a complaint in this instance, there was no case or decision that could be appealed under the APA.”

The deadline for filing a complaint about a regulatory violation has expired, while the absence of an original complaint means there is no case decision available to appeal under the APA.

For WBN, Virginia’s response ends a long fight to have the defeat annulled and removed from Colón’s professional record.

Premier Boxing Champions | PBC on NBC

WBN’s Fight for Prichard Colón

It is no secret that WBN and Prichard were close before the most tragic night of his career ended all contact and left us on the outside for the years leading up to his death.

That never stopped WBN from reporting on Prichard, campaigning for change and hoping lessons from what happened to him could help prevent another fighter and family from enduring the same tragedy.

Virginia’s final response may end WBN’s attempts to have the result changed, but it does not end our commitment to Prichard.

Prichard Colón will not be forgotten.

WBN will continue to keep his name alive whenever and wherever possible with the WBN Boxer Pageand push to ensure his fight for life and everything that happened in its aftermath are never allowed to simply disappear from boxing’s memory.

This investigation ends here, but Prichard’s story does not.


About the Author

Phil Jay is the Editor-in-Chief of World Boxing News (WBN), a BWAA-acknowledged boxing news website founded in 2010. A veteran boxing reporter with 16 years of experience, he has interviewed world champions, broken international exclusives, and reported ringside from major events. His work is published worldwide through WBN and distributed on platforms including Apple News.

Read Phil Jay’s full bio and latest stories.

Continue Reading
Advertisement

OUR NEWSLETTER

Subscribe Us To Receive Our Latest News Directly In Your Inbox!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Trending