Joe Calzaghe says he doesn’t believe Canelo Alvarez is among the greatest boxing champions of all time. He points out that Canelo’s (63-3-2, 39 KO) defeats against good fighters, as well as his controversial win over Gennady Golovkin, make him undeserving of being considered an all-time great in his book.
Spine check: Canelo fails the test
No spine the fact that Canelo has shown he doesn’t want to fight David Benavidez is enough to keep him off the all-time list. By choosing not to fight the “Mexican Monster”, David Morrell or Christian Mbilli showed fans that Canelo is inside pure jelly and he is not worthy of sitting among boxing’s all-time greats on Mount Rushmore.
Canelo, 35, has a September 13 “Fight of the Century” in Las Vegas after a 12-round unanimous decision loss to 154-pounder Terence Crawford. Canelo had a similarly needy performance during his fight against William Scull earlier this year on May 3, but this time the judges did not give him a decision.
Many boxing fans would agree with retired 53-year-old former two-division world champion Calzaghe that Canelo did not do enough to be among the greatest fighters of all time. Although he defeated many great warriors, many of them were past their prime when he fought them. Additionally, Alvarez has questionable victories over these three:
Gennady Golovkin 1 and 2
Erislandy Lara
William Scull
Austin Trout
The harsh reality of Mount Rushmore
If we’re talking about boxing’s Mount Rushmore status, Calzaghe doesn’t think Canelo will be included. However, if we want to expand the field of players to include others, Terence Crawford also does not think he is the greatest player of all time because his resume is too feeble. Winning division titles against faded competitors matters.
The all-time greats of Mount Rushmore
Sugar Ray Robinson
Muhammad Ali
Henry Armstrong
Jo Louis
“I wouldn’t call him an all-time great because he lost his biggest fights,” said Joe Calzaghe Boxing Scenespeaking of Canelo Alvarez not being rated as an all-time great fighter. “He’s still a great fighter. He had some great wins, but he lost against top fighters, right?
“He lost to Mayweather. I thought he definitely lost one of the Golovkin fights. He has a great career. If you keep fighting, you will lose. Father Time will catch up with everyone. I just hope he doesn’t last too long and doesn’t get beaten by mediocre fighters,” Calzaghe said of Canelo.
Canelo’s best victories
Gennady Golovkin II – * Doubtful
Sergei Kovalev
Caleb’s plant
Billy Joe Saunders
Miguel Cotto
Daniel Jacobs
Callum Smith
Erislandy Lara – *Doubtful
Shane Mosley
Austin Trout – Close
Too many faded enemies, too little risk
These victories were not good enough to earn Canelo a spot in the prestigious all-time top country club. For Canelo to be considered, he would have to show courage by fighting Benavidez, Beterbiev, Jaron Ennis and Christian Mbilli.
Indigent performance
Floyd Mayweather Jr.
Dmitry Bivol
Gennady Golovkin I and II
Erislandy Lara
William Scull
Terence Crawford
Chris Williams is a senior writer for Boxing News 24covering sports since 2013 and reporting on major events around the world. His relationships range from established champions to hungry prospects vying for recognition. Over the years, Chris has worked with many of boxing’s top brass, earning respect for his insightful analysis and insider perspective.
Terence Crawford faced and defeated 42 different opponents during a 17-year career, but super-middleweight icon Carl Froch believes that there is one welterweight who would have put an end to Crawford’s unbeaten streak if they were to meet in their primes.
Crawford became the first post-war boxer to claim the undisputed title in three separate weight divisions last September; a run which began as a super-lightweight in 2015 by defeating Thomas Dulorme, then unifying against Viktor Postol before halting Julius Indongo in an undisputed title showdown.
‘Bud’ then moved on to the welterweight scene and knocked out Jeff Horn to capture the WBO world title on his 147lb debut, making five defences of the title before colliding with fierce rival and three-belt unified titleholder, Errol Spence Jr, in 2023.
In a unforgettable fight, Crawford brutally beat Spence down in an authoritative ninth-round stoppage win to capture the undisputed welterweight throne. Talk then turned to an unprecedented three-weight move up to super-middleweight to take on Canelo Alvarez.
After stopping off at super-welterweight to dethrone Israil Madrimov on his way up, Crawford debuted at super-middleweight in a challenge for Canelo’s undisputed crown and outboxed the Mexican superstar in an iconic win last year, hanging up the gloves three months later.
Despite those legendary achievements, Froch picked Floyd Mayweather Jr to come out on top in a potential fantasy fight against the Omaha southpaw, in an episode of ‘Froch on Fighting’.
Mayweather’s achievements speak for themselves, retiring with a perfect 50-0 unbeaten record after claiming world honours in five divisions, with his most impressive reign coming at 147lbs, where he defeated the likes of Manny Pacquiao and Shane Mosley.
Mayweather has been rumoured to make a comeback, but while there would be huge finances that would be on offer, Crawford has revealed that he would have no interest in ending his retirement for a bout with ‘TBE’, believing that the 49-year-old is ‘old’ and ‘done’.
Terence Crawford has been hailed by many as the best fighter of this generation following his retirement, and now WBC welterweight title hopeful Conor Benn has shared how he thinks ‘Bud’ would have fared against six-division world champion Oscar De La Hoya.
Crawford became boxing’s sixth five-division world champion with an iconic win over Canelo Alvarez back in September; joining Thomas Hearns, Sugar Ray Leonard, De La Hoya, Floyd Mayweather and Manny Pacquiao in that elite and exclusive club reserved only for legends of the sport.
Of that group, only De La Hoya and Pacquiao have gone on to conquer a sixth division, with De La Hoya’s 2004 WBO middleweight world title win over Felix Sturm seeing the Californian become the first boxer to ever become a sextuple champion.
Crawford could have joined ‘’The Golden Boy’ and ‘Pac-Man’ in achieving that feat, having been offered a middleweight world title shot during the aftermath of his triumph over Canelo late last year – a proposal which later fell apart due to a failed doping test by Janibek Alimkhanuly.
Continuing the praise that the Omaha-born southpaw has received since announcing his retirement last December, Benn told Daily Mail Boxing that he would favour the undefeated star to get the better of De La Hoya, if they were to meet in their primes.
Benn also went on to predict that Crawford would retain his unbeaten streak against other greats of the game, picking him to come out on top against each of Mayweather, Julio Cesar Chavez, Pernell Whitaker and Roberto Duran.
Top trainer and former world champion Robert Garcia has considered the outcome of a fantasy showdown between Terence Crawford and Manny Pacquiao.
The two generational greats reportedly came close to squaring off in 2021, back when Crawford was the WBO welterweight champion and ‘Pac Man’ held the WBA title.
Their unification match never materialised, though, as Pacquiao was scheduled to face Errol Spence Jr before ‘The Truth’ pulled out with a torn retina.
Instead, the Filipino legend ended up losing his WBA title to Yordenis Ugas at a stage when, while still serviceable, he was quite clearly past his best.
Crawford, meanwhile, was hitting top form around this time, just a few fights away from producing arguably a career-best performance against Spence.
He did, of course, manage to stop his welterweight rival in nine rounds, before moving up to 168lbs and becoming a three-division undisputed champion by dethroning Canelo Alvarez last September.
Based on those two performances, coach Garcia has told ESNEWS that he would favour ‘Bud’ to defeat even a prime version of Pacquiao.
“The Crawford that beat Spence – and the Crawford that beat Canelo – would probably beat Manny.”
While Crawford’s prime almost certainly came during his run of eight stoppages at welterweight, it is harder to pinpoint when Pacquiao ultimately reached his peak.
In terms of his most destructive performance at world level, however, many will point towards his second-round finish over Ricky Hatton in 2009.
While facing the ‘Hitman’ at 140lbs, Pacquiao would cement himself as a formidable welterweight champion soon after, dethroning Miguel Cotto with a 12th-round stoppage for the WBO title.