Joe Calzaghe says he doesn’t believe Canelo Alvarez is among the greatest boxing champions of all time. He points out that Canelo’s (63-3-2, 39 KO) defeats against good fighters, as well as his controversial win over Gennady Golovkin, make him undeserving of being considered an all-time great in his book.
Spine check: Canelo fails the test
No spine the fact that Canelo has shown he doesn’t want to fight David Benavidez is enough to keep him off the all-time list. By choosing not to fight the “Mexican Monster”, David Morrell or Christian Mbilli showed fans that Canelo is inside pure jelly and he is not worthy of sitting among boxing’s all-time greats on Mount Rushmore.
Canelo, 35, has a September 13 “Fight of the Century” in Las Vegas after a 12-round unanimous decision loss to 154-pounder Terence Crawford. Canelo had a similarly needy performance during his fight against William Scull earlier this year on May 3, but this time the judges did not give him a decision.
Many boxing fans would agree with retired 53-year-old former two-division world champion Calzaghe that Canelo did not do enough to be among the greatest fighters of all time. Although he defeated many great warriors, many of them were past their prime when he fought them. Additionally, Alvarez has questionable victories over these three:
Gennady Golovkin 1 and 2
Erislandy Lara
William Scull
Austin Trout
The harsh reality of Mount Rushmore
If we’re talking about boxing’s Mount Rushmore status, Calzaghe doesn’t think Canelo will be included. However, if we want to expand the field of players to include others, Terence Crawford also does not think he is the greatest player of all time because his resume is too feeble. Winning division titles against faded competitors matters.
The all-time greats of Mount Rushmore
Sugar Ray Robinson
Muhammad Ali
Henry Armstrong
Jo Louis
“I wouldn’t call him an all-time great because he lost his biggest fights,” said Joe Calzaghe Boxing Scenespeaking of Canelo Alvarez not being rated as an all-time great fighter. “He’s still a great fighter. He had some great wins, but he lost against top fighters, right?
“He lost to Mayweather. I thought he definitely lost one of the Golovkin fights. He has a great career. If you keep fighting, you will lose. Father Time will catch up with everyone. I just hope he doesn’t last too long and doesn’t get beaten by mediocre fighters,” Calzaghe said of Canelo.
Canelo’s best victories
Gennady Golovkin II – * Doubtful
Sergei Kovalev
Caleb’s plant
Billy Joe Saunders
Miguel Cotto
Daniel Jacobs
Callum Smith
Erislandy Lara – *Doubtful
Shane Mosley
Austin Trout – Close
Too many faded enemies, too little risk
These victories were not good enough to earn Canelo a spot in the prestigious all-time top country club. For Canelo to be considered, he would have to show courage by fighting Benavidez, Beterbiev, Jaron Ennis and Christian Mbilli.
Indigent performance
Floyd Mayweather Jr.
Dmitry Bivol
Gennady Golovkin I and II
Erislandy Lara
William Scull
Terence Crawford
Chris Williams is a senior writer for Boxing News 24covering sports since 2013 and reporting on major events around the world. His relationships range from established champions to hungry prospects vying for recognition. Over the years, Chris has worked with many of boxing’s top brass, earning respect for his insightful analysis and insider perspective.
Last July, Morrell was scheduled to face Smith for the WBO interim lightweight heavyweight title. Since then, the fight has dragged on through lengthy negotiations, a delayed announcement and then a cancellation when Smith pulled out of the scheduled April 18 fight due to injury. No replacement date confirmed.
This is a classic move to save your career by David Morrell. While the path to the WBO interim title with Callum Smith looked good on paper, the reality, with drawn-out negotiations, Smith’s injury-forced withdrawal from the April 18 event and zero clarity about a reschedule, quickly became a trap.
For a 28-year-old Morrell player who should be successful, waiting forever is a form of professional suicide. He is coming off a win over Imam Khataev and should be aiming for significant fights at 175 pounds. Instead, almost a year passed with no real progress. Mandatory positions can support a challenger, but they can also stall a career when the other side can’t move.
Chelli provides Morrell with rounds, classes and a paycheck, but it’s not a destination. This is a sign that Smith’s route has become unreliable.
Smith may still return this year and the WBO may still maintain order, but Morrell cannot spend his prime months on paperwork and recovery schedules that are not his own. Players lose more than dates when they remain idle. In a crowded division, they lose visibility, timing and position.
May 9 isn’t so much about Zak Chelli as it is about Morrell refusing to let 2026 slip away while others were deciding his next move.
This weekend, Naoya Inoue will fight the iconic fight with Junto Nakatani, which will be the biggest fight in the history of Japanese boxing. After this potentially legacy-defining fight, “The Monster” wants another huge fight.
However, the 32-year-old revealed that his bout with Nakatani will be his second to last at 122 pounds and he plans to stay at heavyweight for one more fight in the division, even though it looks like he’s already gotten over it.
As a result, there have been rumors that Inoue could face unified super flyweight champion and fellow pound-for-pound star Jesse “Bam” Rodriguez – who makes his bantamweight debut against Antonio Vargas in June – before moving up to featherweight and being out of the Texan’s reach.
In the game of “yes or no” with DAZN BoxingInoue confirmed his interest in a fight with Rodriguez and boldly predicted that he would win against the undefeated 26-year-old southerner.
“Yes, [I would love to fight Jesse Rodriguez]”
“[Would I beat him?] Yes.”
Rodriguez will become a three-division champion if he can beat Vargas on Saturday, June 13, but he will usurp Inoue as pound-for-pound king if he were to hand the Japanese sensation the first defeat of his career – provided Nakatani doesn’t do it next Saturday at the Tokyo Dome.
“Bam” Rodriguez also expressed his interest in the fight, saying he would take it without hesitation if one came up. With boxing power broker Turki Alalshikh close to both men, it might just be possible.
This part is settled. The contract is already in force, and the date has been set for the end of 2026. Everything is currently underway in Riyad until July 25.
“To my friends in the UK – it’s happening. It’s signed,” Turki Alalshikh said.
It is not yet known what Joshua’s next fight will be. He still has to go through Prenga in Riyad and come out neat. No cuts, no knockdowns. That’s how these fights fall apart. Not in boardrooms, but in the ring.
Fury (35-2-1) has already taken care of his team. He came back, dealt with Arslanbek Makhmudov and managed the rounds without taking a penalty. He looks like a guy who can still go twelve rounds and still concede a draw when he needs to.
He has had fits, but not against ones that test him under pressure. The loss of Dubois still exists. As the pace slowed and the punches returned, his form faltered and he stayed in range for too long. Something like this can’t happen again without a signed contract.
This time the business side moved first. Turki Alalshikh said straight: “It’s signed,” and Fury supported it. No more delays and shifting dates.
Now all that’s left is execution.
Fury will provide size, clinch work and consistent pace over the distance. Joshua will need excellent timing, a powerful base and a willingness to put his hands down when the opening comes.
The deal is real. July 25 will decide whether this fight stays on track.
Tomek Galm is a boxing journalist covering the global fight landscape since 2014, specializing in heavyweight analysis, industry trends and fighter psychology.
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.