He pointed to names in the division and made it clear that younger belt holders and recent challengers present a different problem than the versions Canelo faced during his title reign.
Malignaggi mentioned 168-pound champions Christian Mbilla and Jose Armando Resendiz, as well as Hamzah Sheeraz.
“He’s teenage, he’s forceful, you can come back from this defeat and this long break, be this age and fight Resendiz, you, and everything is fine,” Malignaggi told Probox TV about Canelo facing a fight with WBA champion Resendiz.
“None of these fights are uncomplicated for Canelo after a long layoff. Neither of them will probably ever fight for a title in the real world again, but they were there and that’s mainly why it’s compelling.”
If Canelo returns in September as planned, he says he wants a champion. But if Malignaggi is right, even a guy like Resendiz may be too much of a driving force for the 35-year-old Canelo, who has been through as many wars as he has.
It must be admitted that there is a colossal difference between Canelo, who fought Gennady Golovkin in a rematch in 2018, and the one who had no ideas in the fight against Terence Crawford last September.
Malignaggi may be a polarizing guy, but he’s looking at the chilly reality of the current 168-pound landscape. When you look at the guys holding the belts, it’s a different world than the one Canelo ran in.
The division was essentially revamped while Canelo was sidelined after elbow surgery and the loss to Crawford. Christian Mbilli, Osleys Iglesias and Jose Armando Resendiz currently hold titles at 168.
Canelo’s style has become too meager. When you’re 35 years antique and undergoing major elbow surgery, relying on single, weighted power shots is a recipe for disaster against the monsters currently wielding the belts.
The Crawford fight was a wake-up call. These recent 168-pound champions are natural super middleweights with engines that won’t stop. If Canelo goes through with his plan to fight the champion on September 12 in Saudi Arabia, he will face a completely different physical challenge than the chess match with Crawford.
Since the second fight with Golovkin, the resume has been more of a strategic masterpiece than a competition one. Fights with Avni Yildirim, Billy Joe Saunders and Caleb Plant allowed him to unite, but none of these guys had enough firepower to really hurt him.
Even Berlang and Munguia’s fights felt like high-profile exhibitions, designed to keep the money flowing without risk.
The two times Canelo actually stepped outside of that comfort zone against elite, unsafe talents Dmitry Bivol and Crawford, he was defeated.
Dan Ambrose is a boxing journalist at Boxing News 24, respected for his direct analysis and extensive coverage of the global fight landscape. His reports focus on the most essential fights, division development and the most discussed stories in sports.