Opinions & Features
The Olympic Games should be a celebration of sporting achievements
Published
6 months agoon
The Paris Olympics should be a celebration of all that is good about sports. But despite the usual incredible heroics in the arena, boxing was once again tainted by controversy from virtually every conceivable angle, not least in the scoring criteria, where many fights were fraught with cries of theft. Claims that in some cases have much truth.
However, many of the headlines focused on Lin Yu-ting from Taiwan and Imane Khelif from Algeria. Much of the noise is a huge case of misrepresentation and blatantly false and uninformed reporting.
Neither was born male. Both have always competed in the women’s ranks with varying degrees of success. Lin Yu-ting is a former two-time amateur world champion and has wins over current undefeated WBC featherweight champion Skye Nicolson (below). Imane Khelif competed at the Tokyo Olympics and won a silver medal at the 2022 World Amateur Championships.
Without going too far into the medical side of this story, Boxing News Imane Khelif has written before, which simplifies the matter, as does everything else I’ve read on the subject:
Sources say doctors have determined the 25-year-old has a disorder of sex development (DSD), which can cause women to have XY chromosomes and the same testosterone levels as men. Women typically have two X chromosomes, while men typically have an X and a Y chromosome.
‘South African runner Caster Semenya, who won gold in the 800 metres at the 2012 and 2016 Olympics, had a similar condition. Semenya was controversially forced to take medication, such as the contraceptive pill, to lower her testosterone levels.’
The details of the ongoing, now non-toxic dispute have been detailed elsewhere many times. To put it bluntly, the International Boxing Association (IBA) disqualified both fighters from last year’s World Amateur Championships after they were found to have failed gender-specific qualification tests, even though both fighters were already deep in the tournament. However, the International Olympic Committee (IOC) cleared both fighters to compete in Paris.
On Thursday, Mark Adams, an IOC spokesman, issued the following statement:
“I will reiterate that all the competitors are following the rules of eligibility for the competition and that is how it should be. That is how these boxers have competed in these Games, that is how they have competed in previous world championships, that is how they have competed in previous Olympic Games and that is how they have competed in regional and continental competitions. They are following the rules of eligibility and I think that is how it should be and that is how it can be.”
The two organizations are currently at odds over the future of boxing at the Olympics. They are divided on many issues. The eligibility of Imane Khelif and Lin Yu-ting are just some of the many differences that separate them.
But potentially the most sedate, at least in the low term. If any issue requires a unified position, and one based on actual medical facts, this is it. Different rules depending on which side of the street you live on. Boxing in a nutshell.
The ongoing disputes between the IOC and the IBA threaten the continued participation of boxing in the Olympic arena. But more importantly, the dispute over the right of Khelifa and Yu-ting to fight in Paris does no good to the sport or to any of the competitors, especially the two in the eye of the storm. Everyone is involved in an impossible situation. And one that could and should have been avoided.
Khelif and Yu-ting did nothing wrong. They are not transgender, as many people with very enormous platforms falsely claim. People who, quite frankly, should know better. Both fighters have been subjected to unimaginable online shaming and harassment. The scrutiny and abuse they have had to endure in recent days has been simply disgusting. They were allowed to fight. They showed up to fight. That’s all they did. The fault, if any, is none of theirs. If you think they shouldn’t be competing in Paris or anywhere else, direct your venom in the right direction. And do so armed with facts.
Amy Broadhurst, who defeated Khelif two years ago, expressed her opinion, saying: “I think it’s the way she was born and it’s out of her control. The fact that she’s been beaten by nine women says it all.”
Skye Nicolson, who sparred with both competitors and was defeated by Yu-ting, also spoke out in defense of both competitors. There were others.
Even Italian fighter Angela Carini, the boxer who pulled out of her fight with Khelifa in Paris after just forty-six seconds, has now dramatically changed her stance.
“All this controversy makes me depressed. If the IOC said she could fight, I respect that decision. I want to apologize to her and everyone else. I was livid because my Olympics went up in smoke.”
Not all online coverage is negative, but unfortunately most of it is, almost all based on a lack of understanding of the facts. As we saw on the streets of Britain last week, mob rule does not make you right. Sometimes you just need a bit of balance.
But leaving aside all the hype and division surrounding Khelifa and Yu-ting, I think the issue can be narrowed down to the following:
Should Khelif and Yu-ting be punished for the condition they were born with? But regardless, is it fair to everyone if they are allowed to fight? Is it really fair competition? And most importantly, is it safe and sound for Khelif and Yu-ting to continue boxing?
Two-weight world champion Natasha Jonas (below) says:
“I don’t blame the two athletes one bit. But if it’s unfair, for whatever reason, it’s still unfair. Athletes have a right to compete on equal terms. The IOC has already set a precedent by banning an athlete from non-contact sports.
“So not doing it in a contact sport where the goal is to hurt someone else, I think it’s outrageous. You just can’t have one rule for one person and another for someone else. If you make a rule, it has to apply across the board, but especially in combat sports.”
Jonas’ key words are, “If it’s unfair, no matter the reason, it’s still unfair.” We just need an answer.
As UK Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy said in an interview with Sky News this week, it is about finding a balance between integration, fairness and security.
As a former runner, I remember Caster Semenya’s athletics career very well. It was obvious that the South African had much more strength and stamina than her peers. The results and the times tell us that. If that translates to boxing, we definitely have a problem. We shouldn’t be in that situation. Khelif and Yu-ting shouldn’t be in that situation either. As Jonas added, “No boxer should be in a situation where they’re being forced or pressured not to fight.”
Khelif and Yu-ting haven’t just come out in the last few years. They’ve had extensive amateur careers. But that doesn’t mean we don’t have a problem. Studies in horse racing, for example, seem to indicate that women are more susceptible to concussions.
Add to that the obvious dangers of boxing, the urgency of solving this is paramount. Simply put, we need these answers. And swift. All concerned need clarity on many issues.
All we need to know is: do Khelif and Yu-ting pose a greater risk to their opponents? If the answer is yes, the decision is very effortless to make. But it also works the same way if the answer to the above question is no.
But regardless of the answer to that question, the appropriate authorities simply need to address it. This is not someone who just runs around the track a few times.
You may like
Opinions & Features
Jesse Rodriguez is raising the temperature in the lower weight classes
Published
2 months agoon
December 1, 2024JESSE RODRIGUEZ he became known as one of the best warriors in the world.
The 24-year-old has been making his way through the lower weight classes since winning his first world title in February 2022, and after a devastating seventh-round victory over Mexican legend Juan Francisco Estrada in May this year, ‘Bama’s meteoric rise to fame shows that there are slight signs of slowdown.
“Yes. It was a great fight. I feel like it was my best performance so far in my career,” Rodriguez said Boxing news.
“Especially against an opponent like Estrada. He’s a legend in all of boxing, so to treat him the way I did says a lot about who I am.
“This [the Estrada fight] it was a little different just because it was his territory, being in Phoenix, but I handled it well too. So, like I said, it just shows that not only as a fighter, but as a person, this is who I am.”
A fight with Estrada would give Rodriguez a chance to showcase a side of his game that hasn’t been required before: his drive.
Billed as a “Passing of the Torch” between vintage and modern generations, the action itself lived up to the lofty pre-fight expectations. Estrada was knocked down in the fourth round before returning the favor in the sixth; he sent Rodriguez to the canvas for the first time in his career with a pointed right hand.
“Yes. I mean, it was a learning experience,” Rodriguez smiles.
“Now that I look back, I should have listened to my coaches. They told me not to get too comfortable: that’s what I did. That’s why I ended up on the canvas. I just have to draw conclusions, pay attention, not be inactive and just listen to the coach all the time.
The lesson has been learned. Quick. After stabilizing the ship in the sixth set, Rodriguez finished the round on top, then in the remaining seconds of the seventh, he delivered a crushing left uppercut to the mid-section where Estrada went down again. This time the referee counted to 10 as “El Gallo” lay flat on his back and writhed in agony and Rodriguez was elated.
Estrada, a proud champion making the first stoppage in his storied 48-fight career, quickly signaled his intention to invoke his contracted rematch clause. Of course, he was the first to take Rodriguez down, and for at least part of the fight he was as competitive as anyone on ‘Bama.
However, the rematch would not take place; and Estrada decided to go in a different direction as he neared the end of his Hall of Fame-worthy career. Who could blame him? Especially when we remember again the sickening impact of the body shot that amazingly ended his reign as champion.
“Oh yes, that’s what we expected [the immediate rematch] right after the fight.
“It was already written in the contract that there would be a rematch. I mean, we waited about two months to find out he pulled out and that’s why we ended up here fighting Pedro Guevara. [in Philadelphia on November 9]. But I mean, that’s the way it is. It’s his decision. Ultimately, I have to be respectful.”
Estrada’s withdrawal means Rodriguez will face Mexican Guevara, who, although coming off a career-best win following his last win over Australian Andrew Moloney, is a far cry from the top-flight opponents who have brought the best out of Rodriguez so far.
Nevertheless, “Bam” remains focused on repeating his stellar performances against some of the sport’s top names, although he will enter the fight as the clear favorite. For most, the only question is how decisively Rodriguez will get rid of Guevara, which will be an unimaginable failure.
“I feel like for others it’s an exhibition fight, but for me it’s as unsafe as my previous two fights. I’m on pound for pound list, so I have to go out there and correct it.
“I don’t want to try too strenuous to look impressive. I just have to go out there and approach this fight like I would any other fight. In my last two fights I performed as well as I need to do on November 9. Come fight night, I’ll be ready to operate what I’ve learned from these fights and I’ll be more ready mentally and physically.”
Rodriguez’s return also means he will be one half of a tantalizing modern “double act” alongside IBF welterweight champion and promotional stablemate Jaron “Boots” Ennis. The duo, both associated with Eddie Hearn’s Matchroom Boxing, are widely regarded as two of the future superstars of American and even world boxing.
With the event taking place at the 21,000-capacity Wells Fargo Center in Ennis’ hometown of Philadelphia, Rodriguez himself is excited to showcase his talents to a modern audience, this time on America’s East Coast. To do so alongside another fighter of Ennis’ caliber is another welcome bonus.
“This is a huge opportunity for me, not only to fight on a large card, but also to show my fighting style on the East Coast.
“I have never fought on the East Coast, even as an amateur. “It’s a chance to showcase my skills, my career, and to share it with ‘Boots’ – one of the best in all of boxing – it’s an honor.”
The pairing of two of boxing’s top talents has been largely well-received by boxing fans, with “Boots/Bam” joining “GGG/Chocolatito” and more recently “Benavidez/Tank” as a infrequent opportunity to see the two stars – the fighters are apparently content to share spotlights.
However, there is no hiding the fact that both Ennis and Rodriguez enter their fights as clear favorites. While Ennis has so far struggled to secure fights against the biggest names in the welterweight division, Rodriguez has already boasted a string of top-level victories in his relatively tiny top-level career.
After dominant victories over three of the consensus “Four Kings” in the super flyweight division: Carlos Cuadras, Srisaket Sor Rungvisai and the aforementioned Estrada, there remains one name that has eluded Rodriguez so far: Nicaraguan great Roman “Chocolatito” Gonzalez.
It was previously believed that the fight with Gonzalez did not take place, in accordance with the will of Teiken Promotions the mighty Akihiko Honda, who promotes both Rodriguez (alongside Matchroom Boxing) and Chocolatito.
However, recent reports suggest that the fantasy matchup could be back on the table, potentially in 2025 in Saudi Arabia. Although “Bam” quickly denied these reports as “phony news”, he did not rule out a future fight with the legendary four-weight world champion.
“Yeah, I mean, it was kind of phony news. Robert [Garcia] he explained it on Twitter. He said: If there are no unification fights after this fight [Guevara]this is a fight we would be interested in if he did [Gonzalez] is also with this.
“So, if it happens, it happens. If not, there are other fighters I want to fight.”
Rodriguez’s emergence as an elite operator coincided with another rise to power in boxing.
Turki Alalshikh, head of Saudi Arabia’s General Authority for Entertainment, quickly established himself as a key figure in the sport with the launch of the Saudi season in Riyadh events. There are rumors about Rodriguez playing in Riyad during the season card in the near future, it’s an option that not only appeals to the San Antonio native, but is already included in the terms of his contract.
“I have signed a modern contract with Matchroom and [fighting in] Saudi Arabia is indeed included in the agreement,” Rodriguez confirmed BN. “If I’m fighting there, they have my bag ready. This is another place I would like to fight.”
With Saudi Arabia already hosting two undisputed title fights in Fury vs. Usyk and Beterbiev vs. Bivol in 2024 alone, Rodriguez hopes the riches offered by Alalshikh and GEA will allow him to earn his own shot at unifying all four belts at 115 pounds department.
“I feel like if it were up to me, I would fight [WBA and IBF champion Fernando Daniel] Martinez there [in Saudi]focus on indisputability. It would be a great fight.”
Whether the future involves a trip to Arabia, San Antonio, or somewhere in between, Rodriguez, at just 24 years vintage, has already established himself as one of the hottest talents of a generation.
The desert might be the best place for him.
Opinions & Features
Olympic gold medalist Galal Yafai believes his pedigree will show
Published
2 months agoon
December 1, 2024The last time Galal Yafai boxed Sunlit Edwards, he had to take annual leave from his 9-5 factory job. “I wasn’t even a real boxer back then,” he says. “I was just having fun at that point.”
A decade on and the pair are about to collide in perhaps the most vital British flyweight clash in history, and there is no leave application form in sight.
It was April 2015 and Yafai had barely heard the name Sunlit Edwards when he arrived at Echo Arena in Liverpool for the semifinals of the ABA tournament. Yafai lost in Saturday’s competition and Edwards defeated Joe Maphosa in the final 24 hours, but the seed was sown for a rivalry that would last almost a decade.
They met again in Sheffield later that year as they both planned their path to the 2016 Rio Olympics. However, of course, there was only one place for the 49 kg category and it was Yafai who took it after winning the qualification.
It’s a moment that seems to irritate Edwards, considering he was the one who won their earlier competition. But Yafai, never one to get flustered, smiles when asked to tell his side of the story.
“I went to tournaments and won,” he says. “I improved because I quit my job and fought seven or eight times a year. Before that it only happened two or three times a year, so I just improved very quickly. I went from boxing Sunlit in the ABA and taking it seriously to fighting the No. 1 Cuban in the world and having really tough fights with them.
“Nothing against Sunlit, but he lost in the ABA this year as well. Sunlit lost in the finals to a guy named Kiaran MacDonald, so Sunlit knows better than anyone that you can get beat any day by split decision or whatever.
“He lost in the Olympic year to an English kid. If that happens, then he shouldn’t have left and I shouldn’t have left, it should have been someone else. He doesn’t seem to tell anyone about his loss to Kiaran MacDonald. He knows better than anyone else.
While their time together in the UK was somewhat fleeting in the grand scheme of their careers, it was long enough for them to share what Edwards described as “hundreds” of rounds of sparring. But while Edwards nestled at the English Institute of Sport in Sheffield to plow a lonely furrow as a professional, Yafai stayed with Great Britain for two Olympic cycles, the second of which won gold.
Yafai’s decision to start his career with GB’s director of performance Rob McCracken and continue his training in Sheffield also drew criticism from Edwards, who suggested that using the lottery-funded facility gave him an unfair advantage. “McCracken doesn’t pay for his gym,” Edwards said earlier this year. “He receives the best gym in the country, strength and conditioning equipment, an indoor and outdoor treadmill, saunas, steam rooms, massages, and physiotherapy classes for free. You name it, they’ve got it. He can put Sunlit Edwards into their system and they’ll have every fight I’ve ever had in a British ring on TV. Are you telling me it’s a level playing field?
Another smile from Yafai. “I don’t care where I train,” he says. All I need to run is a ring, a bag and my legs. I know Sunlit said I’m making the best of it and that I can watch my sparring. Just watching my sparring doesn’t support. That won’t make me win tonight. To me, that’s really a lot of crap. The gym is a great gym, but I just need a bag and a ring.
He also disagrees with the claim that McCracken always favored him. “Let’s not get it twisted, I’m a flyweight,” he says with a laugh. “I was 28 when I won gold at the Olympics. Rob won’t be a millionaire from me, I’ll tell you that. Rob had Carl Froch and Anthony Joshua. I don’t think when he first saw me, a 100-pound, 150-centimeter elevated little man, he thought, “Yes, this is my way out.” For Sunlit to think that Rob favors me, I think he would prefer a heavyweight that would make him a lot of money.
“Honestly, when I turned professional I thought I would go to America to train with someone, but I thought I got along with Rob and he’s a straight guy. I had confidence in him and thought I’d try it out and see what he wanted to do. It just really happened. I said I’d like to stay there and train with him, and he replied, “We’ll see how everything goes.”
So far it’s gone as well as possible. Yafai is 8-0, 6 KOs and was on the right track from the start, making his debut over 10 rounds against the talented Carlos Bautista in February 2022. He ended it with 2-11 in the fifth over. Still, despite being three years older than Edwards at 31, the southpaw can’t match his opponent’s professional experience.
Surrey-born Edwards, who has spent most of his adult life in Sheffield, is 21-1, 4 KOs and a former world champion with four successful defenses and a reputation as one of the best in the division. That’s why selecting Edwards as his opponent in his first 12-round fight is a bold move on Yafai’s part.
“I think it’s time because I feel better,” he explains. “My team around me also knows that I am better than him.
“I don’t want to go all out on him and say I beat him in sparring, but if Sunlit had beaten me in sparring, the fight wouldn’t have happened at all, so it’s really uncomplicated. Of course, we sparred in the amateur category, but also before my debut.
“When I turned pro, I went to his gym and we sparred for about a month. We sparred twice a week for a month, doing 10 rounds. That’s 20 rounds a week for a month and then again in 2023, I think, so I understood what he meant because he was the world champion at the time and I hadn’t even made my debut yet. I really shouldn’t judge him, but it was a good sparring match.
“But sparring means nothing. This doesn’t mean that if sparring is comfortable for me, I will win this fight. Fighting is the whole thing, it’s a different thing, you have to rise to the occasion. We’ll see tonight, but if I had been beaten during sparring, this fight wouldn’t have happened, trust me.”
The interim WBC flyweight title is at stake at the BP Pulse Arena in Birmingham, despite Kenshiro Teraji only winning the full belt last month. Still, the Second City winner will likely get a chance to fight the champion at some point in 2025. Yafai doesn’t mind.
“I just don’t look too far into the future,” he says. “I don’t even know why there was a provisional title for this film. I don’t care either. I’m not thinking about the Japanese champion or anyone else. Let me get past Sunlit, this obstacle, and then maybe I’ll think about who’s next and what titles will be available, because this could all end quickly if I don’t beat Sunlit next week. Then I’m five hurdles back. Let me get past Sunlit and then we’ll see what Eddie Hearn and the team want to do.
If he loses, I don’t know what he’ll do, and if he wins, I don’t know what he’ll do. It’s either going to be shit for him or for me.
Opinions & Features
Ryan Garcia’s next “fight” highlights boxing’s continuing flaws
Published
2 months agoon
November 29, 2024
BOXING is the Wild West. Or rather, as legendary journalist Jimmy Cannon once said, “Boxing is the red lightweight district of professional sports.”
In any case, it is a sport that deserves the utmost integrity and oversight, protecting competitors from the catastrophic risks associated with their craft.
And yet, in the absence of an overarching governing body to set standards, after all these years there is no effective deterrent when an athlete’s safety is compromised by the exploit of performance-enhancing drugs (PEDs).
Instead of addressing this issue with a high degree of consideration and urgency, the sport has, quite astonishingly, strayed even further from a place of purity where, still, despite the best efforts of those who want to effect change, the rules enforced by each committee remain fundamentally unclear.
Anyone not connected to boxing will ask why Ryan Garcia, an athlete banned by the Up-to-date York State Athletic Commission earlier this year, was given a chance to remain lively.
Of course, his next fight, which will take place on December 30, will only be an exhibition and not a professional fight. Despite this, the 26-year-old will be financially rewarded at a time when his so-called penalty.
What’s more, it’s somewhat astonishing that Garcia, who tested positive for ostarine following his controversial fight with Devin Haney, only received a one-year ban.
As with most scorching fighters, his defense was that trace amounts of the substance were found in his system, indicating that he didn’t actually have an artificial advantage over Haney. However, this excuse, even though it has been used many times, only seems to raise further questions.
First, how did the substance end up in his system? And, perhaps more importantly, what if Garcia had used microdosing techniques – taking smaller doses of ostarine throughout training camp – to circumvent the tests?
In other sports, these questions would be addressed by the governing body responsible for making an informed decision about what happens if an athlete tests positive for PEDs. However, in boxing, a fighter who has been banned by the commission is given the freedom to explore other options – hence Garcia’s exhibition.
This is a problem that fans have tried to deal with, but whose complexity only creates more frustration.
Ultimately, the solution is clear: we need a recognized organization that will have jurisdiction over the entire sport. However, given boxing’s archaic structure, this demand is, well, quite unrealistic.
However, instead of burying our heads in the sand, shouldn’t we pave a path that will at least lead us to a more desirable state of affairs?
Boxing newsafter all, it was based on the same ambition – to see boxing as a good, tidy sport – when John Murray founded its flagship publication in 1909.
That’s why now, more than ever, it’s critical that Murray’s words are at the epicenter of the sport’s fight against PEDs.
As mentioned earlier, one of the biggest problems with drug testing is that once a fighter is found guilty, his punishment is rarely severe enough to discourage other fighters from following suit.
And this can actually be largely explained by the lack of coherence between individual committees.
But what if the Voluntary Anti-Doping Agency (VADA), a trusted organization widely considered the gold standard in drug testing, actually had the authority to act on its findings?
In this sense, every commission around the world, whether they like it or not, would be obliged to adopt VADA’s position on PEDs.
Perhaps this is wishful thinking, but which other organization has the authority to take on such a huge responsibility?
In turn, VADA would be able to alleviate some of the pressure that individual commissions are currently under by eliminating the drawn-out disputes into which militants are often drawn.
Take for example the situation between Conor Benn and the British Boxing Board of Control. Would it instead be wiser for VADA to enforce the ruling based on its own findings?
This way, at least we would know that a group of experts – with extensive knowledge of drug testing – made a decision based solely on scientific evidence, whether anyone agrees with it or not.
Of course, getting two organizations to agree on something is never simple in any industry, let alone boxing.
However, if the world’s leading commissions trusted VADA and agreed to support any rulings made, then boxing would certainly be in a much healthier place.
That said, the legal ramifications that have emerged from the various failed tests conducted in recent years are a very different story, potentially giving VADA less incentive to continue to boost its involvement in boxing – a sport that continues to amaze even the most desensitized fighters. fans.
Liam Cameron on BEN WHITTAKER rematch talks – ‘I KNOW AS MUCH AS EVERYONE ELSE!’
Joseph Parker will be stripped of his title immediately after his fight with Daniel Dubois begins
Nate Diaz CHUGS BEER after BEATING Jorge Masvidal & CELEBRATES in LOCKER ROOM • BEHIND THE SCENES
Max Holloway is on a mission at UFC 212
Cris Cyborg ready to add a UFC title to her collection
Carl Froch predicts that Artur Beterbiev vs Dmitry Bivol
Liam Cameron on BEN WHITTAKER rematch talks – ‘I KNOW AS MUCH AS EVERYONE ELSE!’
Nate Diaz CHUGS BEER after BEATING Jorge Masvidal & CELEBRATES in LOCKER ROOM • BEHIND THE SCENES
Viddal Riley FUMES at ‘Real Fighter’ comments made by DOUBTERS – ‘I DON’T HAVE TIME!’
Trending
-
MMA8 months ago
Max Holloway is on a mission at UFC 212
-
MMA8 months ago
Cris Cyborg ready to add a UFC title to her collection
-
Interviews3 months ago
Carl Froch predicts that Artur Beterbiev vs Dmitry Bivol
-
MMA8 months ago
The Irish showed up in droves at the Mayweather-McGregor weigh-in
-
Interviews3 months ago
Artur Beterbiev vs Dmitry Bivol
-
Boxing6 months ago
Lucas Bahdi ready to test his skills against Ashton Sylve
-
Interviews8 months ago
I fell in love with boxing again
-
Opinions & Features3 months ago
Dmitry Bivol: The story so far