Boxing will crown its undisputed featherlight heavyweight champion on Saturday night when Artur Beterbiev and Dmitry Bivol collide in Riyad.

They are both at the top of the 175-pound weight class and have been for some time, but separating them is a tough proposition.

There will be countless predictions, analyzes and debates this week about a fascinating 50-50 fight where a robust case can be made for either fighter. But what does the boxing industry think? picked the brains of 14 people, from promoters to fighters to broadcasters.

Below is a low selection. To watch more, click on the video.

Ben Whittaker (featherlight heavyweight and 2020 Olympic silver medalist)

“You will probably see interviews [where] I changed and changed. I was very robust towards Beterbiev [and] Beterbiev will probably keep him. But now I’m back in Bivol and I’m thinking about Bivol. Bivol is adolescent, fresher, stays vigorous, can fight close, can fight long and his fitness is good, so I will lean more towards Buffalo“

Shane McGuigan (Head Coach)

“I’m just thinking Beterbiev is in better shape. Bivol looked really good when he boxed Canelo, but he was inactive for some time and didn’t look good in his last fight. Beterbiev looked a little flat and delicate just before boxing Callum Johnson, and then Johnson dropped him. He wasn’t looking well around this time. Now he has recovered. People may say that the Anthony Yard fight was a competitive fight, but that’s not true. He took his foot off the gas pedal, fought in bursts and was very withdrawn that night. And then Callum Smith… Callum is a very good player, so doing this to Callum Smith… is [Beterbiev] in great shape.

Jim Lampley (Lead Commentator and Expert)

“It’s just a great fight. These are two great technicians. They both have power. I think it’s logical to agree with Beterbiev and gain the advantage in striking power. This doesn’t necessarily mean he will win this fight. Bivol, who defeated Canelo Alvarez, extremely confident, commanding his craft, able to choose other options than those in front of him to continue to find success in the slow rounds. He can win this fight. This is 50-50 fight. I can’t wait to see it.”

Jai Opetaia (IBF world cruiserweight champion)

“It’s an amazing fight. Stylistically, a fighter moving forward against a guy who just cuts corners. It’s amazing. As a fan of boxing and the science of the sport… there is a lot of hype around heavyweight fighters because they hit so demanding, but this is chess match and as a science of the sport of boxing, it’s a great fight, a great matchup, and I’m truly honored to be a part of a great fight like this. Any true boxing fan who knows styles and statistics [knows] this fight is massive.”

Gervonta “Tank” Davis now has an official date and location for her second fight of the year.

The No. 8-ranked pound-for-pound fighter will defend his WBA lightweight title against Lamont Roach Jr., who is moving up in weight. Their 12-round fight will be the main attraction of the PBC gala, which will take place on December 14 in the Prime Video Pay-Per-View program at the Toyota Center in Houston, Texas.

The incident was confirmed by PBC on Sunday evening.

Davis (30-0, 28 knockout) will make his second attempt to defend the full version of the WBA lightweight world title. The undefeated Baltimore native previously held the “Regular” version of the belt before being promoted last year following the departure of Devin Haney (31-0, 15 KO; 1 No-Contest) from the division.

Before securing this fight, Davis and his team were looking for a unification fight against reigning IBF lightweight champion Vasily Lomachenko. Such a fight was planned for November, but Lomachenko (18-3, 12 KO) refused and decided to wait out the rest of the year.

Ultimately, a path was created for Roach (25-1-1, 10 knockouts) to enter the equation. The WBA 130-pound world champion was previously summoned at the beginning of the summer for another fight against interim world champion Albert Batyrgaziev. However, a one-time exception was granted to challenge Davis at a higher weight instead.

After the victory, Roach will have to decide whether he will stay at lightweight or return to 130. A loss will force him to face Batyrgaziev (12-0, 8 KO) within 120 days of the Davis fight.

Both Davis and Roach earned eighth-round knockout victories within two weeks of each other against undefeated opponents.

Davis’ moment came against Frank Martin at the PBC Summit on June 15 at Prime PPV in Las Vegas. The fight was fierce until it wasn’t. Davis finally caught up to Martin and knocked him out for the fourth straight time.

On June 28 in Washington, Roach defeated undefeated Feargal McCrory (16-1, 8 KO) in his eighth fight. That night was the first home match in nearly seven years for Roach, the fourth-ranked junior lightweight on The Ring from Upper Marlboro, Maryland.

Before that came his first championship title. Roach scored a dramatic knockout in the 12th round, thanks to which he overtook and eliminated the WBA 130-pound world champion, Hector Luis Garcia (16-2, 10 KO). Overall, Roach won six in a row. His lone loss came by decision in November 2019 to then-WBO junior lightweight champion Jamel Herring in Fresno, California.

Follow @JakeNDaBox

Lamont Roach is a good player. He is technically sound; he is a championship-level player.

However, when it comes to Gervonta “Tank” Davis’ opponents in the pay-per-view event, I would prefer to see someone who has put in an explosive top-notch performance or at least has a polarizing personality.

Davis is a true pay-per-view star. Whether or not you agree that so many of his fights should be on pay-per-view – and I disagreed with most of them – he has been an established presence on pay-per-view for some time. It lacks the appropriate opposition necessary to charge these types of fees.

Roach is a solid fighter. But he hasn’t reached the top and I don’t think his character can compensate for that. He had success in the super featherweight division, but it took some time. Had he defended the title multiple times, the fight between him and Davis might have made more sense, but he took it – against Feargal McCrory.

We’ve seen Davis in this type of fight before – for example against Hector Luis Garcia, who has only lost a split decision to Roach since Davis’ stoppage. But over time it became a pay-per-view model – once a fighter achieves that status, he or she remains on pay-per-view regardless of the opponent.

Frank Martin, Davis’ former opponent, is also a solid fighter and, unlike Roach, fights at lightweight. He was on track to fight Shakur Stevenson and had put in some good performances, which meant he had the highest level of curiosity around him. There is no doubt that Davis is at the highest level and that is why carefully selecting his opponents is frustrating.

It’s also essential that Roach – who is highly talked about by those who know him – is not the biggest fighter in the super featherweight division, where he still seems capable of defending his WBA title, and Davis is such a powerful lightweight fighter. If Davis is the biggest star in the division and Stevenson is his biggest rival, then I feel the same way about this fight as I did when Stevenson fought Joe Cordina. This looks more like a fight that would be acceptable if Davis faced Stevenson and then Stevenson had to withdraw due to injury and be replaced; If we were certain that Davis-Stevenson would be next, it would make a lot more sense, but it doesn’t even seem close.

Davis should be considered a massive favorite. As for Roach, if he won, it would be the event of the year, and a match that could be the disappointment of the year should not be aired on pay-per-view.

The lightweight fight I’m more positive about is the William Zepeda-Tevin Farmer fight. Farmer introduces Zepeda to a different style as he rises to the next level; Farmer is a former world champion and a very crafty southpaw, and fighting him strengthens his hopes of fighting Davis or Stevenson in the future.

Southpaws dominate the lightweight division, making Farmer a very suitable opponent who can show us where Zepeda, who has been impressive so far, is at. Farmer may be past his best form, but Zepeda is not defending his world title, and their fight is a shadow of the fight between Chris Billam-Smith and Gilberto Ramirez. I anticipate moments when Farmer will come out on top and test Zepeda, even though I expect Zepeda to both learn from him and win.

As a side note, when Stevenson-Cordina was announced, we were also told we could expect Stevenson-Zepeda and then Stevenson-Davis in 2025. Stevenson’s presence on Matchroom and DAZN – Zepeda’s broadcaster continues to fight, albeit under Golden Boy Promotions – means a fight between the two wouldn’t be a surprise.

However, I see no reason to believe that Stevenson-Davis will be successful after this. Matchroom has nothing to say about Davis’ moves. I am elated to say publicly that I do not think a Stevenson-Davis event will occur in 2025, and while I expect a Stevenson-Zepeda event to occur, it will happen at the end of the year, not at the beginning as we anticipate” I was also told.