Connect with us

Boxing

Does Olympic boxing provide equal opportunities?

Published

on

The Olympics are no stranger to controversy, and Paris 2024 is no exception. From human and political rights to athlete safety, there are many stories circulating. But the story that seems to have captured the world’s attention is that of Imane Khelif and Lin Yu-ting, boxers from Algeria and Taiwan.

After Khelif and Yu-ting won their first fights, news broke that both boxers had been disqualified from the 2023 Women’s World Championships. Social media erupted and spread the idea that both fighters were transgender. Viral media picked up the story, and the wider boxing and sports world joined in to express their outrage.

This outrage was fueled by Khelif’s opening fight with Italian boxer Angela Carini. The fight lasted only 46 seconds, long enough to see Khelif land several punches before Carini gave up and broke down in tears. The Italian boxer stated that she had never felt such difficult punches and that she simply could not continue fighting. This show of emotion on Carini’s part promoted a forceful public opinion that Khelif had no place in women’s competition.

Imane Khelif and Angela Carini exchange blows (Photo: Richard Pelham/Getty Images)

At first glance, it appeared to be a debate about whether trans women should compete in women’s sports, and Khelif was cast as a trans woman, putting cis women at risk. As the days passed, a photo of a newborn Khelif emerged with a statement from International Olympic Committee (IOC) President Thomas Bach stating, “This is not about a transgender issue. This is about a woman competing in a women’s category.” Given this explanation, we need to take a closer look at why both boxers were disqualified from last year’s World Championships.

The International Boxing Association (IBA) (formerly known as AIBA) claimed that Khelif and Yu-ting failed gender qualification tests because their DNA test results showed that both athletes had XY chromosomes, but the results were never released. The IBA governed Olympic boxing until 2019, when the IOC suspended the organization due to governance, financial, and corruption issues. This made the IBA the first federation to be expelled from the Olympic movement. Khelif was disqualified after defeating Russian boxer Azalia Amineva.

Why are these two boxers only now, at the peak of their careers, being questioned about their gender? Khelif and Yu-ting competed at the 2020 Tokyo Olympics without any fuss, speculation or controversy.

Given the growing debate on equal opportunities, wouldn’t it be a good idea for us to take a closer look at what we really consider to be “level”

The term “difference in sex development” (DSD) (formerly known as intersex) defines a broad spectrum of conditions in which the development of chromosomes, sex organs, and hormones is atypical. Given this spectrum, how do we establish clear but fair guidelines for what is fair and what is not, what we consider a natural physical advantage and what is an unfair advantage?

This isn’t the first time we’ve seen a debate about gender eligibility. The most high-profile case was that of 800-meter runner Caster Semenya, who was asked to take medication to lower her testosterone levels if she wanted to continue competing. But the equivalent discussion surrounding male athletes is one of admiration, classifying elite athletes as superhumans because of their genetic makeup.

Michael Phelps won a staggering 28 Olympic medals in four Olympic games. News outlets and sports commentators were delighted to marvel at his disproportionately enormous arm span, double-jointed ankles, and ability to produce about half the lactic acid levels of his competitors. These unique physiological blessings are no doubt attributed to the fact that the 2000s were known as the “Phelps era.”

We should ask ourselves why we are punishing Semenya, Khelifa and Yu-ting while celebrating Phelps. The tone on social media was accusatory and at times felt like a witch hunt.

Prominent figures from politics and media have weighed in with their own cutting remarks: Donald Trump shared a video of Khelif fighting with the caption, “I WILL KEEP MEN AWAY FROM WOMEN’S SPORTS”; Piers Morgan published a news article under the headline, “Imane Khelif is NOT a biological woman” and separately tweeted a photo of Khelif with the caption, “If that’s a biological woman, then I’m a biological aardvark.”

Are these the words of men trying to protect women’s sports, or are they using this as an opportunity to make a political statement and remind everyone what a woman “should” look like?

I’ve been surprised (and slightly scared) by the speed at which disinformation spreads. The masses gorge on politically charged headlines, excited by the chance to throw out everything they think makes them moral authorities on the internet, without a care in the world to check facts or do due diligence.

The Olympics are the pinnacle of an amateur boxer’s career, but instead of being celebrated for their dedication and talent, Khelif and Yu-ting have become victims of slingshot judgments and media scandals. With the future of Olympic boxing hanging in the balance as it has yet to be added to the LA 2028 program, it would be a shame if this were to be the lasting memory of Olympic boxing.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Boxing

Andrew Moloney is confident that if given the chance, he would have beaten Phumelele Cafu and Kosei Tanaka

Published

on

Andrew Moloney (left) attacks Pedro Guevara – photo: Mikey Williams/Top Rank

Few people were more disappointed than Andrew Moloney when Kosei Tanaka lost his WBO super flyweight belt to Phumelele Cafu at the Ariake Arena in Tokyo, Japan on Monday night.

The 33-year-old Australian veteran was hoping to get a shot at beating Tanaka in the lucrative Japanese market.

Those dreams were dashed when South Africa’s Cafu delivered the performance of his life, knocking out Tanaka in the fifth round and finishing the fight strongly, beating the four-weight world champion by split decision.

“The plan was to target the WBO and really chase the Tanaka fight, but it all fell apart on Monday night,” Moloney (26-4-1NC, 16 KO) told The Ring. “I think the WBO is probably still the direction we go, but I’m not sure if they have a rematch clause or if Tanaka will take it. But after watching the fight yesterday, I would be really confident that I could fight one of these guys and win. We would like to follow this path.

“I would love to fight Tanaka in Japan as a four-division world champion. He’s definitely someone I’ve looked up to and wanted to fight for a long time.

“Last night was a little hard to watch. The way he performed, I’m more confident than ever that I have what it takes to beat Tanaka.

I assume there will be a rematch and I hope that Tanaka will regain the belt and I will be able to return to the ring and climb the rankings, and maybe this fight will still happen.

Tanaka entered Moloney’s orbit four years ago when he debuted at 115 pounds. Earlier this year, it looked like they were also on a collision course, with Moloney being number one in the WBO rankings. However, when an offer was made for the vacant IBF lightweight title fight between Vasily Lomachenko and George Kambosos Jr. in May in Perth, Western Australia, Moloney felt he couldn’t turn her down.

This decision ended in disaster. Moloney faced Carlos Cuadras, who withdrew from the fight with a ruptured Achilles tendon and was replaced by Pedro Guevara. Moloney entered the fight with a torn bicep and was largely reduced to boxing with one hand, which circumscribed his punching power.

Still, Moloney felt he did more than enough to win, and was shocked when Guevara was declared the winner by split decision. He was so disappointed that he announced immediately after the fight that he was leaving the ring, but a few days later he withdrew these comments.

It was a breakthrough moment in his career.

“Looking back, it’s a wonderful thing, but watching the Tanaka-Cafu fight made me think that maybe I would do a lot of things if I could turn back time a little bit,” Moloney explained.

“Before my last fight, I was number one in the WBO rankings and I rejected the option of waiting to fight Tanaka. But the opportunity arose to fight Guevara in Australia for the interim WBC title on a major card, and to be candid, I kind of regretted that the Tanaka fight was hanging in the balance, but ultimately we decided to stay busy and take the opportunity to fight in Australia.

“Also, the injury before the fight was another thing I thought about: will I undergo surgery, keep the top spot and wait for Tanaka, but I made the decision to go ahead with the fight with Guevara. Looking back now, maybe it wasn’t the smartest thing to do. And looking at the way Tanaka fought last night, I thought maybe I should have waited. I’m sure I could beat Tanaka and take the belt away from him.

“So I take some consolation, but unfortunately you can’t turn back time.”

It’s been a frustrating year for Moloney, but he’s still hitting the gym and his team is working to get him another fight. The window of opportunity to box again this year is closing quickly, but he still hopes to return to the ring in December, most likely in his native Australia.

“I really hope so,” he said. “That’s what I’ve been working on. I have been training strenuous at the gym for some time, quite a few months. I hope to return before the end of the year.

“At this stage it will probably be December. I’m trying to block something, but so far no luck. I’m still training away as if the fight was to take place in December, the team is currently working on it and I’m keeping my fingers crossed that we’ll be able to finish it.

“I just hope we can get out before the end of the year, get back into the winner’s circle and start climbing the rankings again.”

Moloney, who fought at bantamweight for the first three years of his professional career before dropping down to super flyweight, surprisingly, said he would even consider moving up to another weight class given the right opportunity.

“It’s a tough time in the super flyweight division,” said Moloney, the eighth challenger to The Ring’s 115-pound title. “There’s a lot going on and it’s always strenuous to plan which route to take because everything changes so quickly. I’d pick Bam Rodriguez to beat Guevara, then there’s talk of a rematch between Kazuto Ioka and Fernando Martinez on Up-to-date Year’s Eve. And then there’s talk of Bama, if they win, fighting the winner of that game in unification. The WBO seems to me the fastest way to win the title, so that’s the path we will follow.

“We have also rejected for some time the idea of ​​moving up to flyweight and getting crack there. There’s also some engaging scene going on there right now, but it’s still uncertain. I’d probably feel a little better at super flyweight, but we’ll have to wait and see what happens with Cafu and Tanaka, but like I said, I’d feel comfortable and confident against either of them, so hopefully he can make it it will happen sooner rather than later.”

Continue Reading

Boxing

Doubts that fuel 19-year-old Benjamin Johnson

Published

on

Despite an impressive amateur resume, welterweight Benjamin Johnson of Springdale, Maryland, enters the professional ring with a shoulder injury.

Johnson will face Kevin Pantoja in a four-round fight at Rosecroft Raceway in Fort Washington, Maryland, promoted by his trainer Lamont Roach Snr’s NoXcuses Promotions. The fight will be broadcast on Saturday on ProBox TV.

Johnson, 1-0 (1 KO), spent just 2:23 in the ring in his professional debut, displaying the quick, aggressive hands that won him multiple national titles. However, 19-year-old Johnson feels an advantage, believing he is being overlooked by his NoXcuses Boxing Gym teammates.

Pantoja, 1-1, 27, has never stopped being a professional – Johnson aims to change that.

“People underestimate me,” Johnson said. “It’s been like that since I was an amateur.”

He added that this underestimation increases his motivation in the gym. Johnson is determined to prove his worth not only to himself, but also to those who doubt him or, worse, don’t recognize him. “I never felt like I was recognized as that guy, so I feel like I’m underappreciated,” Johnson said of his amateur and now professional career.

Johnson sees the fight as a key step in his career, compared to feared forward David Benavidez by some teammates and touted by others as one of the most ready-to-fight prospects in the country.

“I train as much as I can,” Johnson said. “It’s about making a statement. The way you win shows people what you’re capable of, and I’m ready to show my best.

Continue Reading

Boxing

Benavidez Sr. wants Artur Beterbiev after David Morrell

Published

on

Image: Benavidez Sr. Wants Artur Beterbiev After David Morrell

David Benavidez’s father, Jose Benavidez Sr., says he wants undisputed lightweight heavyweight champion Artur Beterbiev if he can defeat “regular” WBA champion David Morrell in a Jan. 25 fight.

Jose Senior believes Beterbiew would be a good fight for Benavidez (29-0, 24 KO). He would also like his son to have Dmitry Bivol because it would give him a chance to beat someone who beat Canelo Alvarez in 2022.

Jose Sr. is still bitter that Canelo chose not to fight Benavidez all these years, and recently mentioned a $200 million asking price to fight him. If Bivol loses the rematch with Beterbiev, it is not worth fighting him.

Artur Beterbiev (21-0, 20 KO) will be the guy Benavidez fights if he defeats Bivol in a rematch in 2025. The second fight is still not confirmed, but it is likely.

Benavidez’s worst nightmare would be if Beterbiev lost his rematch with Bivol and then the two fighters met in a trilogy fight. Benavidez will have to wait until the third fight between these fighters takes place before he can claim the belts.

“David’s next fight will be David Morrell. Everyone is very excited about it. We tried to make this fight for three years, but I think David Morrell needed a little more experience to show the world that he deserves this fight,” said Jose Benavidez Sr. Probox TV David Benavidez’s next fight with Cuban David Morrell will take place on January 25.

Of course, Team Benavidez hasn’t tried challenging to fight Morrell over the last three years because they’ve been the ones ignoring him. If they wanted a fight with Morrell, it would have happened a long time ago.

They waited until now, after Morrell’s unimpressive performance against Radivoje Kalajdzic on August 3 at BMO Stadium in Los Angeles, before deciding they wanted to fight him.

“David called him and said, ‘Hey, I want to do this fight. Let’s make it happen. It was done right away. I’m very excited to fight a newborn talent, a sturdy fighter, and I think it’s going to be a tough fight,” said Jose Senior on how the fight with Morrell ultimately came about.

I hope we get a chance to fight Beterbiev. He won only on Saturday. Hopefully we can achieve that, but right now our focus is on David Morrell. We have to look impressive to get to the next level,” Benavidez Sr. said.

If Benavidez loses to Morrell, Jose Sr. will have to decide which direction to take his son. Will he move it back to 168 pounds or stay at 175, hoping to win one of the belts after Beterbiev’s vacation?

Continue Reading
Advertisement

OUR NEWSLETTER

Subscribe Us To Receive Our Latest News Directly In Your Inbox!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Trending